And the winner is...
Superman Beyond by Angelus Silverhead, JARRO77, and borewood2013He finished with 24 total points, 10 from the poll with 14 bonus for reply.
Followed by a 3 way tie for second...
7+13 Agent Venom by logansam
8+12 The Lizard by regisc
10+10 Hulk by gartanham and logansam
After many close finishes before, Superman Beyond WIP finally won. This will be updated in the Hall of Fame tomorrow but can be seen now at: http://mugenmultiverse.fanbb.net/t3450-mmv-awards-hall-of-fame-updated-12-18-2015
Thank you to everyone who participated, especially those that replied for bonus points for their selections.